Dear Forum members,
I am in the early conceptual stage of a new European Citizens' Initiative and would value your feedback on its scope and legal feasibility.
The Observation: While the GDPR, DSA, and EU AI Act have laid groundwork for data sovereignty, I believe there is a remaining "legal vacuum" regarding Surveillance Pricing.
We are moving toward a reality where "price transparency," a pillar of the Single Market, is being replaced by algorithmic "willingness-to-pay" models. Whether it’s a browser cookie or a physical digital price tag in a store, algorithms are increasingly predicting the maximum a specific individual can afford.
The Concept: A legislative framework (potentially under Art. 114 TFEU) that prohibits the use of personal data/profiling to create individualised prices.
Questions for the Forum:
Does the AI Act’s restriction on "social scoring" or the GDPR’s "automated decision-making" (Art. 22) already provide enough protection, or is a specific "Price Integrity" regulation necessary?
Dynamic vs. Personalized: How can we best define the line between legitimate "Dynamic Pricing" (supply/demand) and "Surveillance Pricing" (personal data-driven) to ensure the proposal is proportionate?
Enforcement: What mechanisms would be needed for consumers to verify they aren't being "surveilled" during a transaction?
I am currently looking for feedback and initial connections with people residing in different EU Member States who are interested in refining this concept into a formal Citizens' Committee.
Looking forward to your insights.
The opinions expressed on the ECI Forum reflect solely the point of view of their authors and can in no way be taken to reflect the position of the European Commission or of the European Union.

Leave a comment