Skip to main content
European Citizens´ Initiative Forum

Ban personalized and cohort-based advertisements

Author: Inactive user |
Updated on: 20/04/2021 |
Number of views: 710

Modern advertisement landscape very much lives through the tracking and hoarding and storing of private data such as browsing history, app activity, and other behavioral data.

This data is so valuable to advertisers and ad networks, they will do almost anything to squeeze the last drop of data from people visiting websites and applications, in order to have the "best knowledge" on how to display the most "relevant" advert to the user in various places.

What this creates in an unhealthy ecosystem where users are abused and where all their movements are tracked very precisely, only to make selling advertisements easier.

My idea would be to outright ban adverts that are based on personal data (e.g. browsing history, previous purchases, etc.) or cohort data (users such as myself and similar to me who visit similar websites, etc.).

This ban would largely dissolve the perverse tracking and data hoarding ecosystem created by the modern advertisement industry, and would help everyone move towards healthier alternatives when it comes to advertising.

More work needs to be done to define what defines an advertisement, in order to spot holes that advertisers might come up with, for instance saying that an element on a web page is merely an announcement, not an advertisement. Similarly personalized direct marketing should be reviewed in terms of being opt-in, and not being subscribed by default.

Current situation where users are incentivized to take the easiest route to skip with advertiser preferences as the default enabled option is not good enough. Users are still being tricked to offering their personal data to advertisers due to dark patterns and confusing language.

A ban on the output of the data being collected with questionable means and goals would be an effective measure to make a clear statement that we care about our citizens and their privacy and safety.

1
Vote

Leave a comment

To be able to add comments, you need to authenticate or register.

Comments

Luca Valorosi | 06/05/2021

As you already pointed out users can already opt-out of personalized adversiting. I don't know if forcing big companies to not collect data for personalized adv is the solution, as those companies will limit (or worse stop) to work in EU.

I think a better solution would be to ask users if they want personalized ads or not, when they subscribe to the service. In this case users will be prompted to choose if opt-in or out (if this choice is missing the account can't be created) and companies don't have a strict ban that can compromise the avaliability in EU.

To be able to add comments, you need to authenticate or register.
Julia Hadjikyriacou | 24/06/2021

Advertising offers people access to free information. However this agreement of giving data as revenue to help tailor ads to be relevant to the user is being abused. 

Full transparency is required. The GDPR is simply not enough.

My suggestion would be to have a list of all types of cookies and trackers that exist and an option to personally select which permissions are allowed in the browser settings and that these permissions then apply to all websites.

To be able to add comments, you need to authenticate or register.
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed on the ECI Forum reflect solely the point of view of their authors and can in no way be taken to reflect the position of the European Commission or of the European Union.
Ready to register your initiative?

Want to support an initiative? Need to know more about current or past initiatives?